Blistered Shishito Peppers with Homemade Comeback Sauce

Sharing is caring!

As we look forward to summer with its promise of outdoor dining and the bounty of fresh produce, there’s no dish quite as simple, yet profoundly satisfying as blistered shishito peppers. Paired with a homemade comeback sauce, this dish is a testament to the joys of minimal ingredients yielding maximum flavor. Whether you’re trying shishito peppers for the first time or they’re a staple in your kitchen, this shishito peppers recipe is bound to become one of your favorite things.

Jump to Recipe

What You Need for the Peppers

Creating perfectly blistered shishito peppers is an easy task with a few key ingredients and steps. Here’s an expanded look at how to achieve that irresistible char and flavor, including the crucial final touches that make all the difference.

Essential Ingredients and Tools

1 tbsp Tallow or Butter

Choosing a high-smoke-point fat like tallow or even avocado oil can add a subtle flavor to the peppers. Butter, on the other hand, introduces a hint of richness.

1 Pint of Shishito Peppers

Fresh shishito peppers are the star of this dish. Look for bright, firm peppers without any blemishes.

Cast Iron Skillet

The heavy, even heat of a cast iron skillet is perfect for achieving the blistered exterior that gives these peppers their name.

Cooking Process

Heat the Skillet

Place your cast iron skillet over medium heat to medium-high heat, allowing it to come up to temperature. This step is crucial for achieving the perfect sear on the peppers.

Cook the Peppers

Add the tallow or butter to the skillet, followed by the shishito peppers. The key to perfect blistering is not overcrowding the pan, which ensures each pepper gets enough heat and surface area to char.  If you would like a more colorful or expansive dish add green onions, grape tomatoes, or even canadian bacon here as well.

Turning for Even Blistering

After about 5-6 minutes, when the peppers have started to char on one side, give them a flip to ensure even cooking. They should be turned only once to maintain the integrity of their delicate skins.  Some areas may look burnt, while other areas are more of a golden brown.

The Finishing Touch

Draining and Seasoning

Once the peppers are beautifully blistered and tender, which takes about 10-12 minutes, transfer them to a plate lined with a paper towel. This step helps absorb any excess oil, ensuring your peppers aren’t greasy but perfectly charred and appetizing.

Sprinkle with Sea Salt

While the peppers are still hot, sprinkle them generously with sea salt. The salt not only enhances the natural flavor of the shishito peppers but also adds a textural contrast to the tender, blistered skins.

Serving Suggestions

Serve the blistered peppers hot, with the comeback sauce on the side for dipping. The peppers, with their mild heat and a lot of moisture, pair wonderfully with the tangy, rich sauce, creating a flavor profile that dances on the palate. This dish works beautifully as a side dish, appetizer, or a snack to accompany your summer gatherings.

Crafting the Homemade Comeback Sauce

Comeback sauce, a beloved condiment from the Southern United States, is known for its creamy texture and versatile flavor profile that pairs wonderfully with everything from vegetables to crab cakes. This special sauce combines pantry staples to create a sauce that’s tangy, spicy, and utterly irresistible.

Ingredients for a Perfect Blend

1/4 cup Mayonnaise

The base of the sauce, mayonnaise adds creaminess and helps to blend the flavors seamlessly.

1 tsp Ketchup

Adds a hint of sweetness and tang, enhancing the sauce’s complexity.

1 tsp Hot Sauce

Choose your favorite brand to introduce a spicy kick that can be adjusted to your heat preference.

1 tsp Worcestershire Sauce

 Imparts a deep, savory umami flavor that’s essential to the sauce’s character.

Salt and Pepper

Season to taste, balancing the sauce’s flavors.

The Art of Mixing

Combine in a Small Bowl:

Start by adding the mayonnaise to a small bowl. This will serve as your mixing ground for incorporating the other ingredients smoothly.

Whisk in Flavor Enhancers:

Add the ketchup, hot sauce, and Worcestershire sauce to the mayonnaise. Using a whisk or a fork, mix the ingredients until you achieve a smooth, uniform consistency. The goal is to ensure that each component is well integrated, contributing to the sauce’s overall flavor.

Season and Adjust:

Taste the sauce and season with salt and pepper as needed. At this point, you can adjust the ingredients according to your preferences. If you desire more heat, add a bit more hot sauce. For extra tanginess, a splash more Worcestershire sauce can do the trick.

Customizing Your Comeback Sauce

Adding Citrus:

For a fresh twist, consider squeezing a bit of fresh lime juice into the sauce. The acidity brightens the flavors, making it even more refreshing.

Herb Infusion:

Finely chopped fresh basil, fresh cilantro or parsley can add a vibrant, herby dimension that complements the creamy base wonderfully.

A Touch of Garlic:

A small minced garlic clove or a dash of garlic powder can introduce a subtle bite that elevates the sauce’s complexity.

Serving Suggestions

The beauty of comeback sauce lies in its versatility. While it serves as an excellent dipping sauce for blistered shishito peppers, it can also be used to dress salads, as a topping for burgers, or as a condiment for sandwiches. Its rich flavor profile makes it a go-to sauce for adding an extra layer of deliciousness to a wide range of dishes.

Alternate Sauce Ideas for Blistered Shishito Peppers

While the creamy tang of comeback sauce pairs beautifully with the mild heat of blistered shishito peppers, experimenting with different sauces can turn each bite into a new culinary adventure. Here are some alternate sauce ideas to consider:

Smoky Mustard Aioli

Combine mayonnaise, Dijon mustard, a dash of smoked paprika, and a squeeze of lemon juice for a smoky, tangy dip. This smokey mustard aioli sauce has a creamy texture and smoky undertones make it a robust counterpart to the peppers’ subtle heat.

Avocado Ranch

Blend ripe avocado, sour cream, fresh herbs (like dill and parsley), garlic, and buttermilk for a smooth, herby ranch that adds a refreshing touch. Its creamy consistency and herbaceous flavor complement the blistered peppers beautifully.

Chipotle-Lime Crema

Mix sour cream or Mexican crema with chipotle peppers in adobo sauce and lime juice for a sauce with a spicy kick and a citrusy zest. This combination brings a lively contrast to the peppers, perfect for those who enjoy a bit of heat.

Asian-Inspired Soy-Ginger Sauce

Stir together soy sauce, grated ginger, a bit of honey, and sesame oil. Add a sprinkle of sesame seeds for an Asian twist that’s both savory and slightly sweet, offering a unique flavor profile that pairs well with the peppers.

Horseradish Garlic Aioli

For a sauce with a bite, mix mayonnaise with freshly grated horseradish, minced garlic, lemon juice, and a touch of olive oil to create a smooth aioli. The horseradish provides a spicy, pungent kick that’s beautifully offset by the creamy mayonnaise, while the garlic adds a depth of flavor that makes this sauce a memorable accompaniment to the peppers. 

Why Choose Shishito Peppers?

Shishito peppers are a mild pepper variety, with the occasional pepper offering a bit more heat. Their small green peppers have thin skin that make them perfect for quick cooking, resulting in a deliciously smoky and slightly sweet flavor. Finding them has become easier as they gain popularity on restaurant menus and are readily available at grocery stores like Trader Joe’s and Whole Foods.

Conclusion

Blistered shishito peppers with homemade comeback sauce represent the best of simple, flavorful cooking. This dish is a celebration of fresh ingredients, the joy of homemade sauces, and the pleasure of sharing good food with loved ones. Whether served on a warm summer evening or as a special appetizer, it’s a dish that’s sure to earn a spot in your rotation of appetizers.

Sharing is caring!